questel_logo
closeClose
  • Patent
    menu-bracket
    • Our Patent solutions
      • → menu-arrowIP Intelligence SoftwareNew
        IP Intelligence Software
        Streamline the journey from innovation to IP with our IP intelligence software, patent search, data analytics, and related services and tools.
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Orbit Intelligence
        Powerful patent searching and analysis
        AI-Classifier
        Artificial intelligence for patent classification
        Prosecution Pack
        Grant statistics and detailed legal status analysis
        Chemistry
        Small molecules searching and analysis
        Orbit Biosequence
        DNA and amino acid searching and analysis
        Orbit Insight
        Explore new markets and opportunities
        Orbit Express
        Easy patent searching and collaboration
        Orbit Intellixir
        Analysis from any scientific sources
        Ask Sophia, your AI agentNew
        Unlock AI-powered use cases across a range of Questel software.
        SEP DatabaseNEW
        Standard Essential Patent Data & Analytics
        Latest resources
        • → Smart Patent Research for True IP Professionals
          The value of a patent search hinges on two key factors: data quality and the intelli...
        • → A Guide to Bio Sequence Patent Searching
          Bio sequence patent search is a unique type of life-science search requiring special...
        • → The World’s Leading 5G SEP Owners – 2025
          Explore the 2025 rankings of the top 5G SEP owners in our latest report. Learn how g...
      • → menu-arrowIP Management Software
        IP Management Software
        Keep your assets up to date and aligned with your corporate strategy with our Equinox suite of IP management software, data analytics, and eBilling tools
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Equinox Corporate
        Powerful all-in-one IPMS for corporates
        Equinox Corporate+
        IPMS tailored for large corporates, built on Salesforce
        Equinox Law Firm
        Powerful all-in-one IPMS for law firms
        Equinox Law Firm+
        IPMS tailored for large Law Firms
        Equinox Invention
        Collaborative invention-to-filing workflow
        Latest resources
        • → Equinox Corporate+ – Leveraging Salesforce for Large IP Portfolio Owners
          IP management is evolving fast to keep up with a rapidly changing landscape. In this...
        • → Transform How You Manage Your IP Portfolio with Equinox IP Management Software
          By integrating data, services, and artificial intelligence (AI) capabilities, modern...
        • → A Goal to Boost Efficiency by 30%: Why Brandstock Chose Equinox Law Firm
          Driven by its goal to deliver the “best IP service to clients,” leading law firm Bra...
      • → menu-arrowPreparation & Prosecution CopilotsNew
        Preparation & Prosecution Copilots
        Optimize your entire patent process with our range of advanced Preparation & Prosecution Copilots, from patent application drafting to prosecution workflow automation, claims mapping, and office action responses.
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Workflow AutomationNEW
        All-in-one patent prosecution workflow, data, and collaboration workspace.
        AI-DraftingNEW
        Industry-leading patent drafting software powered by generative AI.
        Claim MappingNEW
        Patent Mapping and Claim Analysis with AI
        Office ActionsNEW
        Patent Office Action Response Management with AI
        Prosecution Statistics
        Leverage the power of data to guide your patent prosecution with Prosecution Pack
        Latest resources
        • → 5 Challenges for IP Professionals in the Next 5 Years—and How to Overcome Them
          Artificial intelligence (AI) is a hot topic in the IP sector due to its potential to...
        • → Pathways to Productivity: What our 2025 Industry Outlook Research Reveals About AI in IP
          Discover what our 2025 Industry Outlook Research reveals about AI adoption by the IP...
        • → 3 Cutting-Edge Solutions to Support Your R&D and Innovation Strategies
          Discover how the latest cutting-edge software and AI-elevated processes for research...
      • → menu-arrowPatent Services
        Patent Services
        Benefit from end-to-end support for vital but time-consuming administrative tasks with our complete range of patent support services, including searches, translations, international filings, validations, unitary patent management, recordals, renewals, and more
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Search
        Patentability, Freedom-To-Operate, Invalidity
        International Filing Support
        PCT & national phase, Paris Convention, Unitary Patent
        Unitary Patent Support
        Unitary Patent and Unified Patent Court services
        EP Validation
        Simplified European validation services
        Translation
        Centralized patent translation services
        Renewals
        Fee and renewals management
        Recordals
        Assignment and recordal of all IP Rights
        Latest resources
        • → Questel Services Portal - User Webinar
          Are you making the most of QSP for international filings, European patent support an...
        • → What You Need to Know About Maintaining Intellectual Property Records 
          Maintaining intellectual property records can be complicated for in-house legal team...
        • → Should You Outsource Intellectual Property Management Services?
          Whether you manage a small portfolio or multiple large ones, intellectual property m...
      • → menu-arrowPatent Strategy & Administration
        Patent Strategy & Administration

        Control costs, streamline invoices, and safeguard your patent rights efficiently with our patent strategy & administration services and tools

        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Administrative Support
        End-to-end IP admin, data verification and docketing
        Invoice Management
        Invoice review, bundling and payment
        Cost Management
        Fee audits, negotiation, compliance, benchmarks and forecasting
        IP Consulting
        Landscaping, benchmarking, valuation and licensing
        Defensive PublicationBUY ONLINE
        Publish an invention into the public domain
        Latest resources
        • → 4 Good Reasons to Outsource Trademark Docketing
          Trademark docketing requires time, effort, and resources, placing a strain on many b...
        • → Should You Outsource Intellectual Property Management Services?
          Whether you manage a small portfolio or multiple large ones, intellectual property m...
        • → 3 Cutting-Edge Solutions to Support Your R&D and Innovation Strategies
          Discover how the latest cutting-edge software and AI-elevated processes for research...
  • TrademarkNew
    menu-bracket
    • Our Trademark solutions
      • → menu-arrowClearance & Watch Platform
        Clearance & Watch Platform
        Screen and monitor your brand and trademark rights effectively with our trademark clearance search and trademark monitoring platform
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Markify ProSearch™
        Screen trademarks with AI-driven search technology
        Markify Comprehensive SearchBUY ONLINE
        AI-driven trademark availability software
        Markify Full Pharma Search
        Best-in-class trademark results paired with key pharmaceutical sources
        Markify Watch
        Watch for new, identical and confusingly similar trademarks
        Markify Brand Monitor
        Monitor marketplaces, social media, and web content
        Latest resources
        • → From Detection to Defense: A Powerful Duo that Tackles Trademark Proof of Use
          Could your or your competitors’ rights be vulnerable to revocation based on non-use ...
        • → Artificial Intelligence and IP: What’s on the Horizon for AI and Trademarks?
          Discover what’s on the horizon for artificial intelligence and IP, including powerfu...
        • → Crossing the Frontier with AI Trademark Search: Where Algorithms Intersect with Human Expertise
          From manual analysis to AI trademark search, discover how combining AI algorithms wi...
      • → menu-arrow IP Management Software
        IP Management Software
        Manage and maintain your trademark, design and domain name rights effectively with our state-of-the-art trademark management software
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Equinox Corporate
        Powerful all-in-one IPMS for corporates
        Equinox Corporate+
        IPMS tailored for large corporates, built on Salesforce
        Equinox Law Firm
        Powerful all-in-one IPMS for law firms
        Equinox Law Firm+
        IPMS tailored for large law firms
        Equinox Brand Proposal
        Collaborative worklfow for trademark and design proposals
        Latest resources
        • → Equinox Corporate+ – Leveraging Salesforce for Large IP Portfolio Owners
          IP management is evolving fast to keep up with a rapidly changing landscape. In this...
        • → 4 Good Reasons to Outsource Trademark Docketing
          Trademark docketing requires time, effort, and resources, placing a strain on many b...
        • → Transform How You Manage Your IP Portfolio with Equinox IP Management Software
          By integrating data, services, and artificial intelligence (AI) capabilities, modern...
      • → menu-arrowAI Assistants for Trademark ProductivityNew
        AI Assistants for Trademark Productivity
        Review trademark search and watch results, create first drafts of goods and services descriptions, classify evidence of use, and manage office action responses effectively with our AI assistants for trademark productivity.
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Workflow AutomationNew
        All-in-one digital trademark workflow automation
        Search & Watch Review with AINew
        Chat with trademark search or watch results to review findings and assess risk
        Goods & Services Description DraftingNew
        Save time and build consistency and compliance with our AI solution
        Office Action Response with AI New
        Analyze content and draft answers with AI
        Proof of Use ManagementNew
        Manage trademark evidence of use with AI
        Latest resources
        • → 5 Challenges for IP Professionals in the Next 5 Years—and How to Overcome Them
          Artificial intelligence (AI) is a hot topic in the IP sector due to its potential to...
        • → From Detection to Defense: A Powerful Duo that Tackles Trademark Proof of Use
          Could your or your competitors’ rights be vulnerable to revocation based on non-use ...
        • → Experience AI Copilots in Action: The All-in-One IP Solution That Supercharges Patent & Trademark Productivity
          To stay innovative when developing new products and processes in a fast paced enviro...
      • → menu-arrowTrademark, Design & Domain Services
        Trademark, Design & Domain Services

        Access expert support throughout the complete brand lifecycle with our integrated domain name, design, and trademark solutions

        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Search
        Analyst-driven searches with on-demand and customizable reporting
        Watch
        IP asset monitoring with intelligent pre-selection
        Online Brand Protection
        Case management and take-down services
        Filing
        International registration process support
        Renewals
        Trademark and design renewal services
        Domain Name Management
        Effective management of corporate domain names
        Recordals
        Assignment and recordal of all IP rights
        Administrative Support
        End-to-end IP admin, data verification, docketing
        Latest resources
        • → What You Need to Know About Maintaining Intellectual Property Records 
          Maintaining intellectual property records can be complicated for in-house legal team...
        • → Trademark and Brand Protection Hot Topics: a discussion about trends and news from IACC & INTA
          Our teams attended INTA and IACC, key events in the intellectual property world. The...
        • → What is the Ideal Trademark Renewal Timeline?
          With trademark protection lasting only 10 years, renewing your registration is the o...
  • Innovation
    menu-bracket
    • Our Innovation solutions
      • → menu-arrowInnovation Management Software New
        Innovation Management Software
        Make your innovation management processes faster, efficient and scalable with our end-to-end suite of innosabi innovation management software.
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        innosabi Insight
        Business-oriented dashboards for innovators
        innosabi Startup
        Startup deal flow and program management
        innosabi Idea
        Collaborative idea and innovation management
        innosabi Community
        Customers co-creation and communities
        innosabi Partner
        Partners co-innovation and open calls
        innosabi Project
        Innovation Project Management
        Ask Sophia, your AI agentNew
        Unlock AI-powered use cases across a range of Questel software.
        Latest resources
        • → 5 Reasons to Invest in Innovation Management Software
          Translating innovative ideas into successful products is becoming increasingly compl...
        • → 9 Ways to Build a Successful Innovation Culture
          To embed innovation fully into their organizations, companies are often told they ne...
        • → 3 Cutting-Edge Solutions to Support Your R&D and Innovation Strategies
          Discover how the latest cutting-edge software and AI-elevated processes for research...
      • → menu-arrowInnovation Services
        Innovation Services
        Successful innovation processes and culture are about more than the right software tools. Our innovation services leverage proven methods and approaches to generate insights, ideas, and solutions.
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Innovation Consulting
        Market screening, Competitive intelligence and Technology scouting
        Operational Services
        Connect with partners, improve or localize your innovation process
        Naming
        Products and services naming
        Software Localization
        Seamless user experience to a global audience
        Marketing Translation
        Engage with new audience globally
        Latest resources
        • → 7 Key Questions to Measure Innovation Management Success 
          Innovation is the key to staying competitive in today’s fast-paced business world. H...
        • → Software Patent: How Can It Be Done?
          Even though life without computers is today nearly impossible to imagine, patent-bas...
        • → What is Innovation Scouting?
          Change is a constant. New technologies surface regularly and change existing product...
  • SolutionsAI
    menu-bracket
    • Solutions
      • → menu-arrowArtificial Intelligence in IPNew
        Artificial Intelligence in IP

        Discover Questel’s holistic and responsible approach to artificial intelligence
        and intellectual property and our vision to inspire the future of IP with AI

        → Read more
        Our solutions
        AI Adoption Trends
        Discover how AI is transforming IP
        AI Patent Drafting
        Industry-leading patent drafting software powered by generative AI
        AI Copilots for Prosecution
        AI copilots for optimized patent preparation and prosecution workflows
        AI Patent Classification
        AI copilot for automated patent classification
        AI Trademark Search
        AI copilot for elevated trademark clearance search
        Ask Sophia, your AI agentNew
        Unlock AI-powered use cases across a range of Questel software.
        Proof of UseNew
        Capture Trademark Evidence of Use with AI
        Latest resources
        • → The Future of IP Departments: Are We Headed Toward a World of Only Chatbots and AI?
          In this on-demand session, industry leaders from Questel and Better Ipsum discuss ho...
        • → Pathways to Productivity: What our 2025 Industry Outlook Research Reveals About AI in IP
          Discover what our 2025 Industry Outlook Research reveals about AI adoption by the IP...
        • → Leverage Artificial Intelligence to Simplify Your Prosecution Work
          Unlock exclusive insights and discover how Qthena, the AI-powered prosecution assist...
      • → menu-arrowIntegrated IP Ecosystem
        Integrated IP Ecosystem

        Optimize your intellectual property assets with our comprehensive IP portfolio management solutions,
        ensuring maximum protection and strategic advantage for your business.

        → Read more
        Our solutions
        IP Management Software
        IP management systems, docketing, forecasting, data analytics, blockchain, and eBilling tools
        IP Services Portal
        Our web-based platform for IP services management
        Renewals Connector
        PAVIS Connect, our solution for companies and laws firms that already have an IP management system
        Integrated Trademark Watch
        Access trademark watches directly from Equinox with Markify Watch integration
        Latest resources
        • → Switching to a New IPMS: What Does the Data Migration Process Involve?
          When you’re considering switching to a new IP management system (IPMS), you’ll likel...
        • → When Is the Right Time to Upgrade Your IP Management Software?
          When you are overloaded by IP administrative tasks and deadlines, switching to a new...
        • → The Power of IPMS Technology for IP Lifecycle Management
          By choosing an end-to-end integrated IP management system (IPMS), you can build effi...
      • → menu-arrow Solutions for Law Firms
        Solutions for Law Firms
        Streamline internal processes, satisfy client demand, and remain competitive with our specialist solutions for law firms
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Workflow Automation
        All-in-one patent prosecution workflow, data, and collaboration workspace.
        AI Office Action
        Patent Office Action Response Management with AI
        AI Patent Drafting
        Industry-leading patent drafting software powered by generative AI
        Equinox Law Firm
        Powerful all-in-one IPMS for law firms
        Orbit Intelligence
        Powerful patent searching and analysis
        Trademark Clearance and Watch
        Screen and monitor your trademark rights effectively with our Markify platform
        Legal Translation
        Streamline multilingual matters with fast and reliable legal translation services
        Patent Translation
        Centralized patent translation services
        Patent Renewals
        Fee and renewals management
        Trademark Renewals
        Trademark and design renewal services
        Latest resources
        • → How Equinox Law Firm Supports Redchip Lawyers to Save Time and Build Relationships
          For law firms with large, multi-disciplinary practices, an IP management system (IPM...
        • → Can Your IPMS Help Build Strong Client Relationships?
          Cultivating strong client relationships is incredibly important for IP law firms. Yo...
        • → Leverage Artificial Intelligence to Simplify Your Prosecution Work
          Unlock exclusive insights and discover how Qthena, the AI-powered prosecution assist...
      • → menu-arrowSolutions for Life Sciences
        Solutions for Life Sciences

        Intellectual property management tools, services, and insights to support life sciences innovation strategies

        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Orbit BioSequence
        DNA and amino acid searching and analysis
        Orbit Chemistry
        Small molecules searching and analysis
        Orbit Insight
        Explore new markets and opportunities
        Markify Full Pharma Search
        Best-in-class trademark results paired with key pharmaceutical sources
        Equinox Corporate
        Powerful all-in-one IPMS for corporates
        Life Science Translation
        Translation solutions across the product lifecycle—from patent to post-market
        Patent Translation
        Centralized patent translation services
        Patent Renewals
        Fee and renewals management
        Trademark Renewals
        Trademark and design renewal services
        Best IP Tech ProviderNEW
        LSPN North America Awards recognize Questel
        Latest resources
        • → Patent Data Analytics, It’s Not Just for Patent Searching
          There are many reasons why organizations may conduct patent searching exercises and—...
        • → Harnessing the Power of Patent Analytics
          Patent analytics can reveal new application areas, diversification opportunities, an...
        • → The Technology Landscape of Precision Medicine: An IP Analysis
          Technological developments in gene sequencing, imagery, and data analysis are enabli...
      • → menu-arrowSolutions for R&D and Innovation
        Solutions for R&D and Innovation

        Strengthen, structure, and maximize your R&D and innovation strategy, workflows, and internal processes by harnessing the latest tools and technologies, including through smart application of generative AI.

        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Innovation Management Software
        Create more efficient and scalable innovation management processes
        Equinox Invention
        Collaborative invention-to-filing workflow
        Equinox Brand Proposal
        Collaborative worklfow for trademark and design proposals
        Innovation Consulting
        Market screening, competitive intelligence, and technology scouting
        AI for R&D Workflows
        Streamline your research and development workflows with AI
        Latest resources
        • → 3 Cutting-Edge Solutions to Support Your R&D and Innovation Strategies
          Discover how the latest cutting-edge software and AI-elevated processes for research...
        • → 7 Key Questions to Measure Innovation Management Success 
          Innovation is the key to staying competitive in today’s fast-paced business world. H...
        • → AI Patents: What Patent Mapping Can Tell Us About Future AI Technologies
          Artificial intelligence (AI) is evolving all the time thanks to the growing quantiti...
      • → menu-arrowLanguage Solutions
        Language Solutions

        Translation, interpretation and tech-enabled localization services and language solutions that help global organizations open up new markets, overcome regulatory hurdles and connect with audiences worldwide. 

        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Legal
        Streamline multilingual matters with fast and reliable legal translation services
        Life Science
        Translation solutions across the product lifecycle—from patent to post-market
        Corporate Localization
        Manage operations, ensure compliance, and maintain consistent messaging worldwide
        Latest resources
        • → Employing A "Winning Strategy" For Your International Matters
          Year after year, in-house legal teams and outside counsel handling international and...
        • → The Role Clinical Trial Translation Plays in Patient Recruitment and Retention
          Health equity is an essential goal in modern healthcare, and one pivotal aspect of a...
        • → The difference between a legal interpreter and a legal translator
          Attorneys, courts and case law often conflate the need for legal translators or lega...
  • Resources
    menu-bracket
  • Contactmenu-bracket
More
    • Learn & Supportmenu-bracket
      • Learn and support
          • Webinars & Eventsmenu-bracket
            Are you interested in attending one of our online or onsite event?
          • Product Trainingsmenu-bracket
            Customer success is our priority. Increase your skills in the use of Questel’s software
          • Product Newsmenu-bracket
            A platform dedicated to software and platforms news and evolutions
          • Best-in-class Customer Experiencemenu-bracket
            Our goal is to exceed our clients' expectations and share best practices
          • IP Trainingmenu-bracket
            Increase the IP-IQ of your entire organization with engaging IP training programs
          • Newsletter subscriptionmenu-bracket
            Sign up for our quarterly patent and trademark newsletters and set your email preferences below.
          • Resource Hubmenu-bracket
            Stay up-to-date with industry best practices with our latest blogs
    • About Questelmenu-bracket
      • Careers →menu-bracket
        • Login Pages →menu-bracket
          • Learn & Supportmenu-bracket
            • Learn and support
                • Webinars & Eventsmenu-bracket
                  Are you interested in attending one of our online or onsite event?
                • Product Trainingsmenu-bracket
                  Customer success is our priority. Increase your skills in the use of Questel’s software
                • Product Newsmenu-bracket
                  A platform dedicated to software and platforms news and evolutions
                • Best-in-class Customer Experiencemenu-bracket
                  Our goal is to exceed our clients' expectations and share best practices
                • IP Trainingmenu-bracket
                  Increase the IP-IQ of your entire organization with engaging IP training programs
                • Newsletter subscriptionmenu-bracket
                  Sign up for our quarterly patent and trademark newsletters and set your email preferences below.
                • Resource Hubmenu-bracket
                  Stay up-to-date with industry best practices with our latest blogs
          • About Questelmenu-bracket
            • Careers →menu-bracket
              • Login Pages →menu-bracket
              EN
              questel-menu
              Patent invalidity searching: Is that granted patent enforceable?
              Blog Post / Published, September 8, 2023

              Demystifying Patent Invalidity Searching: A Comprehensive Guide with Orbit Intelligence

              Back to Resource hub
              Back to Resource hub
              overview

              Patent invalidation searches probe into the foundations of a granted patent's validity, offering invaluable insights into its enforceability. Bin Wu, Senior IP Solution Consultant at Questel, discusses the complexities of patent invalidity searching and explains how Orbit Intelligence can help to demystify the process.

              In the intricate world of intellectual property (IP), understanding the nuances of patent validity is paramount. The strength of a patent lies in its immunity to challenges posed by prior art. This pivotal assessment, known as an invalidation search, delves into the core of a granted patent's validity, offering invaluable insights into its enforceability.

              Decoding Patent Invalidity

              Patent invalidation, also known as an opposition or validity search, is a meticulous inquiry to ascertain the validity of one or more claims within a granted patent. It seeks to establish if prior art exists that could potentially challenge the patent's validity.

              In essence, it is a litmus test for the enforceability of a patent. The term ‘prior art’ encompasses information related to a patent that has been published worldwide in any language, predating the patent's first filing date.  A patent that emerges unscathed from an invalidation search can be deemed robust and resilient.

              When and Why it Matters

              The need for a patent invalidity search arises in various pivotal scenarios:

              • Licensing Negotiations: Parties engaged in licensing negotiations may conduct an invalidation search to gauge the potency of a patent. A weak patent can significantly impact the terms of the license.
              • Patent Infringement Lawsuits: Companies facing allegations of patent infringement may undertake an invalidation search to unearth prior art or other grounds that could nullify the asserted patent.
              • Mergers and Acquisitions: In the due diligence process of mergers and acquisitions, scrutinizing a company's IP portfolio is imperative. This includes validating the strength of the patents they hold.
              • Post-Grant Proceedings: Even after a patent has been granted, it remains susceptible to challenge. Parties may utilize an invalidation search to uncover prior art or other justifications for initiating post-grant proceedings such as inter partes review or ex parte reexamination.
                 

              While there are other applications, the potency of this tool in safeguarding a company's interests concerning a patent is undeniable, be it in investment ventures or legal disputes.

              The Patent Invalidity Search Process: A Three-Stage Journey

              Patent invalidity searching comprises a three-stage journey:

              Stage 1: Understanding the Patent Claims and Building Your Search Statement

              The cornerstone of any invalidation search lies in comprehending the patent claims and crafting a robust search statement. This initial step demands a thorough examination of the patent to address key queries, such as:
               

              • What is the technical domain of the patented innovation?
              • What precise technical problem does it solve?
              • What sets the patented invention apart from prior art, in terms of means and characteristics?
              • What broad concepts and features are outlined in the claims?
              • What constitutes the novelty of the patented invention?
                 

              Once the searcher gains a lucid understanding of the invention, the next stride is to pinpoint the key features of the patented innovation, answering the aforementioned queries. These key features should encompass the novel and inventive-step aspects identified during the prosecution.

              Our powerful patent searching and analysis platform Orbit Intelligence consolidates patent family citation information, streamlining the identification of these crucial aspects across various jurisdictions (see example pictured below).

              Orbit Intelligence and patent invalidity searching screenshot

              Stage 2: Designing a Search Strategy

              With the key features in hand, the searcher embarks on the task of constructing search strategies to unearth both patent and non-patent publications that reveal one or more of these features. This can encompass a spectrum of sources, from in-force, issued patents to technical papers and articles.

              Orbit Intelligence presents an extensive array of non-patent literature resources, enabling the searcher to explore both realms in parallel:

              Non-patent literature used in patent invalidity searching

              The searcher can then decide whether to create search strings for each key feature individually or amalgamate two or more in a single string to compile a dataset. It's an iterative process, meticulously designed to include all pertinent patent publications and exclude as much extraneous noise as possible. The searcher sifts through the dataset manually, ensuring relevance to the key features, while also keeping an eye on the technology domain and budget constraints.

              Building an effective patent invalidity search strategy requires searchers to follow five high-level steps, namely:

              1. (1) extracting relevant keywords to search;
              2. (2) identifying relevant classification codes from the various international patent classification systems;
              3. (3) formulating (and reformulating) logical search strings;
              4. (4) searching for forward and backward citations; and
              5. (5) searching by inventor/patent assignee.

              –> For more detail on each of these steps, please read our article 'Five High-Level Steps in Patent Search Strategy Building'.

              Stage 3: Analyzing Search Results

              The searcher analyzes the search results after finalizing the search strategies and/or building the dataset. This stage typically consists of two steps: preliminary screening and detailed review.

              1. Preliminary Screening

              The objective of this step is to eliminate irrelevant references that show up in the search results due to co-incidental combination(s) of keywords and/or classes. The searcher takes about minutes on average to review a reference to ascertain potential relevancy to the key features of the invention. The searcher discards the references that do not clearly relate to the field of interest. Therefore, if a reference has the slightest chance of being relevant to the field of interest, then the searcher does not eliminate it from the dataset and includes it in a list for detailed review. Note that the dataset extracted after the preliminary screening step might have irrelevant publications.

              In Orbit Intelligence, ‘Key content’ covers ‘Object of Invention,’ ‘Advantages of the Invention Over Previous Art,’ and ‘Independent Claims,’ which will be extremely helpful to the searcher in screening the result.
              Key content used for patent invalidity searching in Orbit Intelligence

              2. Detailed Review

              The searcher reviews the dataset obtained after excluding the clearly irrelevant references from the initial dataset. The detailed review involves reading excerpts of the patent references in light of the key features. Having said that, the actual time may vary based on the length of the reference document.

              Orbit Intelligence has many functionalities to enable the searcher to review the details of the patent documents, including:

              • Kwic (Key Words in Context)
                This displays the keywords of a search in context, meaning the number of hits for the keywords in select fields. All fields in the entire family searched, if they contain the keywords, are displayed. It also contains:

                (1) A summary by searched fields, where the table cells are colored following a blue shade scale:  the more hits, the darker the cell.
                (2) A summary by hit keywords, where the table cells are colored following a blue shade scale: the more hits, the darker the cell.
                (3) A text excerpt displaying all the abstracts, titles, claims, etc. in the family if those fields contain the keywords. The keywords are shown in bold.

                Keyword search for patent invalidity in Orbit Intelligence
                 
              • Patent Drawings and Accompanying Descriptions

                Patent drawings screenshot when searching for patent invalidity in Orbit Intelligence
                 
              • Highlighted Keywords

                Highlighted keywords in patent invalidity searches in Orbit Intelligence
                 

              Mastering these foundational elements lays the groundwork for a comprehensive and effective invalidation search.

              Find Out More About Patent Invalidity Searching

              In the dynamic realm of IP, arming oneself with the right tools and knowledge can be the key to success. With Orbit Intelligence as a guide, navigating the intricate process of patent invalidity searching becomes not just a possibility, but a strategic advantage in the pursuit of innovation and competitive edge.

              Find out how you could unlock hidden insights in the global patent database with Orbit Intelligence by requesting a software demo or contacting our specialist IP Solutions Consultants today.

              Bin Wu is responsible for supporting a variety of Questel IP product and service solutions. Before joining Questel, he used to work as an electronic engineer, patent attorney, in-house IP professional, and patent searcher. Wu Bin has more than 15 years of experience in the IP field and is familiar with different kinds of technology intelligence analytics theories and patent prosecution practice.

              Questel

              A world leader in intellectual property and innovation management.

              • Patent
                • IP Intelligence Software
                • IP Management Software
                • Preparation & Prosecution Copilots
                • Patent Services
                • Patent Strategy & Administration
              • Trademark
                • Clearance & Watch Platform
                • IP Management Software
                • AI Assistants for Trademark Productivity
                • Trademark, Design & Domain Services
              • Innovation
                • Innovation Management Software
                • Innovation Services
              • Solutions
                • Artificial Intelligence in IP
                • Integrated IP Ecosystem
                • Solutions for Law Firms
                • Solutions for Life Sciences
                • Solutions for R&D and Innovation
                • Language Solutions
              Stay in touch !
              Your email address is only used by Questel to send you the news, updates and offers. You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking on the unsubscribe link at the bottom of the newsletter. For more information about the Processing of your Personal Data by Questel, please visit our privacy policy page.
              © 2025 Questel. All rights reserved.
              Consent choices
              • Cookies policy
              • Data Privacy Policy
              • AI Policy
              • Legal notice