What is Innovation Scouting?

Change is a constant. New technologies surface regularly and change existing product landscapes and business models. Companies don’t have all knowledge and all technology expertise ready to be used and implemented in products. Leverage ecosystem to fill his expertise gap has become a competitive advantage. Technology scouting and innovation scouting are approaches companies use to navigate today’s fast paced innovative environment and tackle the issue of integrating new know–how into products. In this article we are making the case for technology and innovation scouting. 

What is Innovation Scouting?

Innovation scouting is a combination of open innovation and technology scouting. As outside resources are not in control of one’s company, a suitable method has to be used to identify and keep track of these assets. 

Technology scouting serves to identify relevant technologies, compile necessary information and channel it back into the company. It can support the acquisition process of relevant technological assets in the process of internalizing the missing pieces and complement the IP portfolio. Relevant changes in the environment can be identified and new opportunities for collaboration, partnerships or licensing can be pursuit. 

Open innovation is an innovation strategy that recognises the limits to your own capacity to do research, to invent and develop new products and allows and encourages ideas, technologies and innovations to transcend company boundaries, thus increasing speed of access to relevant information. Many resources – both internal and external – are considered in this approach to drive innovative activity. 

Innovation scouting broadens the scope of technology scouting to extend beyond technology centric point of view. Ideas, marketing trends and know-how sourcing can also be considered valid targets and results. By not only looking at technological assets, but ideas, people and networks it serves and supports shifts in core business and provide impulses to business units. In short, innovation scouting is the extension of technology scouting to fit in the open innovation strategy. 

Why engage in innovation scouting? 

A company’s internal innovative capacity leverages the status quo. Engineers rely on existing and known technologies and associated know-how. However, if you rely on the status quo you are bound to miss disruptive shifts and developments. For this reason you need to be vigilant and observe developments, trends, ideas and innovations outside your company and industry. You cannot have the same business forever.  

Push and pull factors to improve scouting processes

Many aspects can drive you to implement or improve existing innovation scouting processes: 

Globalization forces us to watch and monitor trends and developments at a global level. An integrated approach to aggregate relevant information and screen it is mandatory to understand trends and emerging technologies globally. 

The diffusion of new technologies from one product segment into another can upend existing power balances and catch unprepared companies by surprise. Recently German car manufacturers have noticed they have to build up IT and software competencies to compete with Tesla. 

The increasing speed of innovation and thus shortening of product lifecycles can erode competitive advantages quickly.   

R&D departments have to face these challenges and take on more and more responsibilities while defending budgets. Building up internal resources to embrace opportunities presented by new ideas and technologies puts additional stress on capacities and cannibalizes core R&D activity. 

On the other hand management can take advantage of the innovation ecosystem if embedded correctly: 

By staying on top of developments and keeping tabs on potentially disruptive technologies companies can increase resilience and innovate its product portfolio.   

Understanding and using the innovation ecosystem improves alignment of services, products and business models to market needs. Regularly identifying changes, assessing their relevance and impact enables good innovation management and increased value delivery to customers. 

Proper understanding of trends, technologies and fast access to linked know-how expedites product and service development and reduces your time to market. 

Existing edges on your competition are preliminary. Being great at innovation scouting however, can be a reliable competitive advantage. If you have your organization fine-tuned to develop products with a great market fit by leveraging your ecosystem to find and allow ideas, concepts to crosspollinate into your products and services, you set your company up for success. 

How to engage in innovation scouting? 

Looking at the scope of innovation scouting you have a multitude of different aspects to connect and integrate into your innovation workflows. Therefore, the first question should be, do you want this task done by internal employees or external consultants. Both options have upsides and downsides. 

Internalizing offers complete control and keeps know-how strictly inside the company. However, if people are rarely tasked with scouting activities they cannot become efficient and cannot create the necessary network to utilize on consecutive studies. Technology and innovation scouts have to be proficient networkers, result-oriented and follow a structured approach. 

Externalizing allows you to task specialized consultancies and scouts with expertise in the field of interest who can leverage their pre-existing network to deliver results. Externals can provide an unbiased, neutral perspective which can provide vital impulses to your innovation activity. 

Regardless of internalizing or externalizing: Anybody involved in scouting activities is confronted with a sea of information, many options in following innovation leads and will need a structured approach to navigate this area as well as suitable software tools to combat information overload. Which data sources are relevant and should be analysed? How to analyse data from different sources? What are the interesting technologies and solutions for your topic of interest? Who are active players, academics or start-ups or key opinion leaders in any emerging technology? Where is the R&D being done? What are most prevalent technical concepts? These are just a couple of questions that need answering in the face of fractured and most likely incomplete information. 

Aggregating, cleaning up of data from different sources takes time and effort. Time and effort better spent on analysing and decision-making. Do your employees or external consultancies have proper software tools to reduce time spent on mundane and repetitive tasks? Are they able to focus on the big picture and deriving value-adding conclusions and recommendations? 

At Questel we leveraged the expertise of inhouse IP and innovation experts and created a sophisticated scouting tool, called innosabi Insight. Innosabi Insight provides a comprehensive overview of a specific topic by screening and analyzing global R&D activities including IP, scientific and business data on a global scale to provide you with the most recent and relevant insights. It allows you to see what is being done externally on your topic of interest in terms of data, players and market dynamics. Structured dashboards made up of graphs, trends, collaborative networks, metrics and profiles of organizations such as companies or universities enable fast analysis and speed up extraction of key information and insights for your scouting activities! 

Innovation scouting process 

 Innovation scouting can be separated into multiple phases. Overall the phases are consecutive. It can be necessary to run phases multiple times considering new information. Every phase can consist of multiple steps or modules. As a service the innovation scouting process is flexible and not set in stone. Not all steps are necessary: It depends on the topic, your prerequisites, your know-how and your network. But every step that is necessary has to be handled carefully to deliver quality results. The process is detailed in the figure below. 

Innovation scouting process

A variety of methods and tools can be incorporated to sufficiently satisfy the requirements of your scouting project. As discussed it is possible to internalize the whole project. In case your employees lack experience and know-how, e.g. with regards to patent searching, or outside unbiased impulses to your innovation activity might be desirable, you might consider outsourcing specific parts or the whole project to specialized external consultancies. In the last case the proper specification and listing of your requirements and expected, actionable outcomes have to be clarified and communicated. 

Below is a shortlist of studies that can be incorporated into scouting missions and can inspire your project. 

Innovation scouting process

Competitive intelligence

Start-ups sourcing

Leverage technical information in order to anticipate the market and pinpoint weak signals, market shift and emerging solutions. We identify relevant mega and micro trends, interpret them and reveal their potential. Stay on the cutting edge!

Monitor the development of market players working on similar projects or entering your competitive space. We compare strategies, grade companies and rank your organization to reveal ways to make improvements.

Obtain the profile of the latest start-ups in your domain to be the first to seize opportunities. We provide a 360° analysis of a start-up to help you understand who is the funder, how are the intellectual property risks managed, what is their business model and what part of their technology is disruptive. The perfect tool for every venture capitalists and investors.

Technology and competency mapping

Technology and partners scouting

Ideation and white space analysis

Develop a comprehensive, state-of-the-art technological analysis for a pre-defined field of innovation. The mapping project will help the client understand the latest trends and position their project/company correctly. Cross-analysis of patent and NPL data as well as web info and expert interviews.

Identify technologies, patents, companies worthy of acquisition, R&D partners and experts to accelerate development phases and enable companies to position and secure access to new markets.

Generate and secure new ideas for technological applications by leading challenges and using design or problem-solving theories. Our innovation consultancy helps clients find and define new R&D directions.

Innovation scouting enlarges the scope of technology scouting beyond internal to external resources which is part of an open innovation strategy. It considers not only technologies but includes ideas, networks and partners in an innovation ecosystem. It can foster collaboration among companies, competitors, start-ups or researchers. 

If innovative activity relies on internal know-how you are bound to miss disruptive shifts in your ecosystem. To preserve your business it is necessary to observe developments, trends, ideas and innovations outside your business and technological sector. Innovation scouting is a great method bridge the divide. 

Scouting can be done internally or outsourced. Employees need support with specialized software tools allowing them to be effective and efficient. Externalizing can offer unbiased and objective opinions which can provide refreshing impulses to your innovation activity. The innovation scouting process needs to be adapted and tailored to your informational requirements and objectives. 

Questel’s mission is to facilitate the development of innovation in an efficient, secure and sustainable way. As a one-stop-shop for IP and innovation needs we can support both with state-of-the-art software tools and consulting expertise: 

Innosabi Insight provides a comprehensive overview of a specific topic by screening and analyzing global R&D activities including IP, scientific and business data on a global scale. It allows fast analysis and enables your employees to focus on key information and to create most value for your scouting activity.

Questel has the expertise in innovation and a dedicated team of expert consultants with a global presence. Our consultants are able to cover all technological and scientific domains and all geographies. Our offering includesinnovation scouting projects that will retrieve new ideas, concepts, technologies and innovations adding value to your mission.