questel_logo
closeClose
  • Patent
    menu-bracket
    • Our Patent solutions
      • → menu-arrowIP Intelligence SoftwareNew
        IP Intelligence Software
        Streamline the journey from innovation to IP with our IP intelligence software, patent search, data analytics, and related services and tools.
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Orbit Intelligence
        Powerful patent searching and analysis
        AI-Classifier
        Artificial intelligence for patent classification
        Prosecution Pack
        Grant statistics and detailed legal status analysis
        Chemistry
        Small molecules searching and analysis
        Orbit Biosequence
        DNA and amino acid searching and analysis
        Orbit Insight
        Explore new markets and opportunities
        Orbit Express
        Easy patent searching and collaboration
        Orbit Intellixir
        Analysis from any scientific sources
        Ask Sophia, your AI agentNew
        Unlock AI-powered use cases across a range of Questel software.
        SEP DatabaseNEW
        Standard Essential Patent Data & Analytics
        Latest resources
        • → How to Do a Prior Art Search for Standard Essential Patents
          To search prior art for SEPs effectively, patent searchers need to think beyond trad...
        • → Demystifying Patent Invalidity Searching: A Comprehensive Guide with Orbit Intelligence
          Patent invalidation searches probe into the foundations of a granted patent's validi...
        • → Patent Search Techniques: Five High-Level Steps in Search Strategy Building
          An effective search strategy requires searchers to master a specific set of patent s...
      • → menu-arrowIP Management Software
        IP Management Software
        Keep your assets up to date and aligned with your corporate strategy with our Equinox suite of IP management software, data analytics, and eBilling tools
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Equinox Corporate
        Powerful all-in-one IPMS for corporates
        Equinox Corporate+
        IPMS tailored for large corporates, built on Salesforce
        Equinox Law Firm
        Powerful all-in-one IPMS for law firms
        Equinox Law Firm+
        IPMS tailored for large Law Firms
        Equinox Invention
        Collaborative invention-to-filing workflow
        Latest resources
        • → Can Software Simplify IP Management for Law Firms?
          Innovation is at the heart of the IP industry. But, as a busy law firm, how much tim...
        • → Intellectual Property Management: How to Maximize Performance in the Digital Age
          From deadline reminders to project collaboration, data verification, and the automat...
        • → Finally, an IPMS that ushers IP departments into modernity!
          Discover the power of customization and six tips for modernizing IP management share...
      • → menu-arrowPreparation & Prosecution CopilotsNew
        Preparation & Prosecution Copilots
        Optimize your entire patent process with our range of advanced Preparation & Prosecution Copilots, from patent application drafting to prosecution workflow automation, claims mapping, and office action responses.
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Workflow AutomationNEW
        All-in-one patent prosecution workflow, data, and collaboration workspace.
        AI-DraftingNEW
        Industry-leading patent drafting software powered by generative AI.
        Claim MappingNEW
        Patent Mapping and Claim Analysis with AI
        Office ActionsNEW
        Patent Office Action Response Management with AI
        Prosecution Statistics
        Leverage the power of data to guide your patent prosecution with Prosecution Pack
        Latest resources
        • → How AI is Transforming IP Management for Good
          Discover the holistic and responsible approach to AI that is central to Questel's st...
        • → AI in IP – Generative AI, Beyond a Technological Change
          Unlock the potential of AI with insights from industry experts Benoit Chevalier, Mar...
        • → Leverage Artificial Intelligence to Simplify Your Prosecution Work
          Unlock exclusive insights and discover how Qthena, the AI-powered prosecution assist...
      • → menu-arrowPatent Services
        Patent Services
        Benefit from end-to-end support for vital but time-consuming administrative tasks with our complete range of patent support services, including searches, translations, international filings, validations, unitary patent management, recordals, renewals, and more
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Search
        Patentability, Freedom-To-Operate, Invalidity
        International Filing Support
        PCT & national phase, Paris Convention, Unitary Patent
        Unitary Patent Support
        Unitary Patent and Unified Patent Court services
        EP Validation
        Simplified European validation services
        Translation
        Centralized patent translation services
        Renewals
        Fee and renewals management
        Recordals
        Assignment and recordal of all IP Rights
        Latest resources
        • → [WHITE PAPER] IP RIGHTS in mergers and acquisitions
          IP RIGHTS in mergers and acquisitions Download the white paper ...
        • → State of the art analysis a click away!
          In our rapidly changing world, only R&D teams able to mobilize and manage large volu...
        • → Benchmarking – Defend your market and tackle your competitors
          Assess and evaluate your position in your markets by comparing with your competitors...
      • → menu-arrowPatent Strategy & Administration
        Patent Strategy & Administration

        Control costs, streamline invoices, and safeguard your patent rights efficiently with our patent strategy & administration services and tools

        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Administrative Support
        End-to-end IP admin, data verification and docketing
        Invoice Management
        Invoice review, bundling and payment
        Cost Management
        Fee audits, negotiation, compliance, benchmarks and forecasting
        IP Consulting
        Landscaping, benchmarking, valuation and licensing
        Defensive PublicationBUY ONLINE
        Publish an invention into the public domain
        Latest resources
        • → [WHITE PAPER] Three stages to any IP Strategy
          Three stages to any IP Strategy Download the white paper Questel Intelle...
        • → Checklist for protecting and enforcing your intellectual property rights
          As business becomes more complex and global, the number and variety of intellectual ...
        • → 8 Best practices for an efficient annual legal department budget
          Year after year, every in-house legal department knows that preparing the usual annu...
  • TrademarkNew
    menu-bracket
    • Our Trademark solutions
      • → menu-arrowClearance & Watch Platform
        Clearance & Watch Platform
        Screen and monitor your brand and trademark rights effectively with our trademark clearance search and trademark monitoring platform
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Markify ProSearch™
        Screen trademarks with AI-driven search technology
        Markify Comprehensive SearchBUY ONLINE
        AI-driven trademark availability software
        Markify Full Pharma Search
        Best-in-class trademark results paired with key pharmaceutical sources
        Markify Watch
        Watch for new, identical and confusingly similar trademarks
        Markify Brand Monitor
        Monitor marketplaces, social media, and web content
        Latest resources
        • → The 3 elements to consider when doing a trademark search
          Of course, you do! But you might not be aware of the fact that there are thousands o...
        • → Cut Costs When Conducting Your Crucial Trademark Search
          A trademark search is a necessary and essential part of owning and registering a new...
        • → Picture this: Fast and Affordable Trademark Device Searches
          Thanks to global connectivity, brands can reach almost anyone, and images can be rec...
      • → menu-arrow IP Management Software
        IP Management Software
        Manage and maintain your trademark, design and domain name rights effectively with our state-of-the-art trademark management software
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Equinox Corporate
        Powerful all-in-one IPMS for corporates
        Equinox Corporate+
        IPMS tailored for large corporates, built on Salesforce
        Equinox Law Firm
        Powerful all-in-one IPMS for law firms
        Equinox Law Firm+
        IPMS tailored for large law firms
        Equinox Brand Proposal
        Collaborative worklfow for trademark and design proposals
        Latest resources
        • → Record, timestamp and manage your intangible assets using the blockchain
          Having the ability to demonstrate that your data existed on a particular date and ti...
        • → Gain efficiency, manage your entire IP lifecycle activities on a single integrated platform!
          By combining IP Management Software with data and services, Questel allows you to se...
        • → How can Blockchain & Workflow Monitoring Technologies help Trademark teams
          Discover how to meet the needs of today’s globally connected brands!Trademark depart...
      • → menu-arrowAI Assistants for Trademark ProductivityNew
        AI Assistants for Trademark Productivity
        Review trademark search and watch results, create first drafts of goods and services descriptions, classify evidence of use, and manage office action responses effectively with our AI assistants for trademark productivity.
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Workflow AutomationNew
        All-in-one digital trademark workflow automation
        Search & Watch Review with AINew
        Chat with trademark search or watch results to review findings and assess risk
        Goods & Services Description DraftingNew
        Save time and build consistency and compliance with our AI solution
        Office Action Response with AI New
        Analyze content and draft answers with AI
        Proof of Use ManagementNew
        Manage trademark evidence of use with AI
        Latest resources
        • → Future Proof Your IP Management: Smarter Data, Seamless Services & AI-Powered Efficiency
          Managing intellectual property shouldn't be a maze of disconnected tools, incomplete...
        • → Why, When, and How to Establish Proof of Trademark Use—and Is It Mandatory?
          Depending on the jurisdiction, brand owners may need to provide trademark proof of u...
        • → Artificial Intelligence and IP: What’s on the Horizon for AI and Trademarks?
          Discover what’s on the horizon for artificial intelligence and IP, including powerfu...
      • → menu-arrowTrademark, Design & Domain Services
        Trademark, Design & Domain Services

        Access expert support throughout the complete brand lifecycle with our integrated domain name, design, and trademark solutions

        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Search
        Analyst-driven searches with on-demand and customizable reporting
        Watch
        IP asset monitoring with intelligent pre-selection
        Online Brand Protection
        Case management and take-down services
        Filing
        International registration process support
        Renewals
        Trademark and design renewal services
        Domain Name Management
        Effective management of corporate domain names
        Recordals
        Assignment and recordal of all IP rights
        Administrative Support
        End-to-end IP admin, data verification, docketing
        Latest resources
        • → How to Register a Trademark: What to Do and What Not to Do When Getting Started
          When you have a new brand, product, or even an existing business, it’s of the utmost...
        • → Accenture and Brandstock: Working Collaboratively
          Kristen Poggensee of Accenture discusses the benefits of working with IP management ...
        • → How Brandstock Helped BACARDI Successfully Register Its EU Trademark
          How Brandstock Helped BACARDI Successfully Register Its EU Trademark As leading prof...
  • Innovation
    menu-bracket
    • Our Innovation solutions
      • → menu-arrowInnovation Management Software New
        Innovation Management Software
        Make your innovation management processes faster, efficient and scalable with our end-to-end suite of innosabi innovation management software.
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        innosabi Insight
        Business-oriented dashboards for innovators
        innosabi Startup
        Startup deal flow and program management
        innosabi Idea
        Collaborative idea and innovation management
        innosabi Community
        Customers co-creation and communities
        innosabi Partner
        Partners co-innovation and open calls
        innosabi Project
        Innovation Project Management
        Ask Sophia, your AI agentNew
        Unlock AI-powered use cases across a range of Questel software.
        Latest resources
        • → Gain competitive advantage developing innovation networks
          To stay innovative when developing new products and processes in a fast paced enviro...
        • → Evaluate technology potential
          R & D directors face a set of investment opportunities in different technology devel...
        • → Why is it so hard to build and maintain the capacity to innovate?
          This white paper contains 15 pages of management trends, use cases & solutions for i...
      • → menu-arrowInnovation Services
        Innovation Services
        Successful innovation processes and culture are about more than the right software tools. Our innovation services leverage proven methods and approaches to generate insights, ideas, and solutions.
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Innovation Consulting
        Market screening, Competitive intelligence and Technology scouting
        Operational Services
        Connect with partners, improve or localize your innovation process
        Naming
        Products and services naming
        Software Localization
        Seamless user experience to a global audience
        Marketing Translation
        Engage with new audience globally
        Latest resources
        • → Why is it so hard to build and maintain the capacity to innovate?
          This white paper contains 15 pages of management trends, use cases & solutions for i...
        • → How to build an effective technology scouting framework
          Every day, 1,000 scientific articles are published, 8,000 patents are filed, and ove...
        • → The Best Practices for leading an Open Organization
          This White paper has been created based on the participation of more than 120 R&D an...
  • SolutionsAI
    menu-bracket
    • Solutions
      • → menu-arrowArtificial Intelligence in IPNew
        Artificial Intelligence in IP

        Discover Questel’s holistic and responsible approach to artificial intelligence
        and intellectual property and our vision to inspire the future of IP with AI

        → Read more
        Our solutions
        AI Adoption Trends
        Discover how AI is transforming IP
        AI Patent Drafting
        Industry-leading patent drafting software powered by generative AI
        AI Copilots for Prosecution
        AI copilots for optimized patent preparation and prosecution workflows
        AI Patent Classification
        AI copilot for automated patent classification
        AI Trademark Search
        AI copilot for elevated trademark clearance search
        Ask Sophia, your AI agentNew
        Unlock AI-powered use cases across a range of Questel software.
        Proof of UseNew
        Capture Trademark Evidence of Use with AI
        Latest resources
        • → From AI to Integrated Services: The IP Trends Revealed by Our 2024 IP Outlook Research 
          As part of our 2024 IP Outlook Research, we set out to measure the impact of emergin...
        • → AI and IP: How to Integrate AI into Patent Portfolio Management
          AI-based technologies are increasingly revolutionizing how we manage, maintain, and ...
        • → Leverage Artificial Intelligence to Simplify Your Prosecution Work
          Unlock exclusive insights and discover how Qthena, the AI-powered prosecution assist...
      • → menu-arrowIntegrated IP Ecosystem
        Integrated IP Ecosystem

        Optimize your intellectual property assets with our comprehensive IP portfolio management solutions,
        ensuring maximum protection and strategic advantage for your business.

        → Read more
        Our solutions
        IP Management Software
        IP management systems, docketing, forecasting, data analytics, blockchain, and eBilling tools
        IP Services Portal
        Our web-based platform for IP services management
        Renewals Connector
        PAVIS Connect, our solution for companies and laws firms that already have an IP management system
        Integrated Trademark Watch
        Access trademark watches directly from Equinox with Markify Watch integration
        Latest resources
        • → How to Develop a Robust Trademark Search and Watching Program
          From choosing a trademark to registration and enforcement, the trademark lifecycle c...
        • → The Power of IPMS Technology for IP Lifecycle Management
          By choosing an end-to-end integrated IP management system (IPMS), you can build effi...
        • → When Is the Right Time to Upgrade Your IP Management Software?
          When you are overloaded by IP administrative tasks and deadlines, switching to a new...
      • → menu-arrow Solutions for Law Firms
        Solutions for Law Firms
        Streamline internal processes, satisfy client demand, and remain competitive with our specialist solutions for law firms
        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Workflow Automation
        All-in-one patent prosecution workflow, data, and collaboration workspace.
        AI Office Action
        Patent Office Action Response Management with AI
        AI Patent Drafting
        Industry-leading patent drafting software powered by generative AI
        Equinox Law Firm
        Powerful all-in-one IPMS for law firms
        Orbit Intelligence
        Powerful patent searching and analysis
        Trademark Clearance and Watch
        Screen and monitor your trademark rights effectively with our Markify platform
        Legal Translation
        Streamline multilingual matters with fast and reliable legal translation services
        Patent Translation
        Centralized patent translation services
        Patent Renewals
        Fee and renewals management
        Trademark Renewals
        Trademark and design renewal services
        Latest resources
        • → Leverage Artificial Intelligence to Simplify Your Prosecution Work
          Unlock exclusive insights and discover how Qthena, the AI-powered prosecution assist...
        • → Can Your IPMS Help Build Strong Client Relationships?
          Cultivating strong client relationships is incredibly important for IP law firms. Yo...
        • → How Equinox Law Firm Supports Redchip Lawyers to Save Time and Build Relationships
          For law firms with large, multi-disciplinary practices, an IP management system (IPM...
      • → menu-arrowSolutions for Life Sciences
        Solutions for Life Sciences

        Intellectual property management tools, services, and insights to support life sciences innovation strategies

        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Orbit BioSequence
        DNA and amino acid searching and analysis
        Orbit Chemistry
        Small molecules searching and analysis
        Orbit Insight
        Explore new markets and opportunities
        Markify Full Pharma Search
        Best-in-class trademark results paired with key pharmaceutical sources
        Equinox Corporate
        Powerful all-in-one IPMS for corporates
        Life Science Translation
        Translation solutions across the product lifecycle—from patent to post-market
        Patent Translation
        Centralized patent translation services
        Patent Renewals
        Fee and renewals management
        Trademark Renewals
        Trademark and design renewal services
        Best IP Tech ProviderNEW
        LSPN North America Awards recognize Questel
        Latest resources
        • → The Technology Landscape of Precision Medicine: An IP Analysis
          Technological developments in gene sequencing, imagery, and data analysis are enabli...
        • → Harnessing the Power of Patent Analytics
          Patent analytics can reveal new application areas, diversification opportunities, an...
        • → Patent Data Analytics, It’s Not Just for Patent Searching
          There are many reasons why organizations may conduct patent searching exercises and—...
      • → menu-arrowSolutions for R&D and Innovation
        Solutions for R&D and Innovation

        Strengthen, structure, and maximize your R&D and innovation strategy, workflows, and internal processes by harnessing the latest tools and technologies, including through smart application of generative AI.

        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Innovation Management Software
        Create more efficient and scalable innovation management processes
        Equinox Invention
        Collaborative invention-to-filing workflow
        Equinox Brand Proposal
        Collaborative worklfow for trademark and design proposals
        Innovation Consulting
        Market screening, competitive intelligence, and technology scouting
        AI for R&D Workflows
        Streamline your research and development workflows with AI
        Latest resources
        • → 6G technology: Reconfigurable Intelligent Surface patents and the next generation of mobile networks
          By enabling use of 6G technology, innovation in Reconfigurable Intelligent Surfaces ...
        • → Handling a Brand Project Made Simple, Thanks to Equinox Brand Proposal
          Discover how Equinox Brand Proposal can help you to manage your Design & Trademark p...
        • → AI Patents: What Patent Mapping Can Tell Us About Future AI Technologies
          Artificial intelligence (AI) is evolving all the time thanks to the growing quantiti...
      • → menu-arrowLanguage Solutions
        Language Solutions

        Translation, interpretation and tech-enabled localization services and language solutions that help global organizations open up new markets, overcome regulatory hurdles and connect with audiences worldwide. 

        → Read more
        Our solutions
        Legal
        Streamline multilingual matters with fast and reliable legal translation services
        Life Science
        Translation solutions across the product lifecycle—from patent to post-market
        Corporate Localization
        Manage operations, ensure compliance, and maintain consistent messaging worldwide
        Latest resources
        • → Best practices for medical device labeling translations
          The heavily regulated medical device industry often requires translating necessary d...
        • → Translation: a key component of FCPA compliance white paper
          In response to millions of illegal payments made out by U.S. corporations to obtain ...
        • → The Ultimate Guide to Selecting a Dependable Translation Partner for Technical Documentation
          When it comes to technical documentation, choosing the right translation partner can...
  • Resources
    menu-bracket
  • Contactmenu-bracket
More
    • Learn & Supportmenu-bracket
      • Learn and support
          • Webinars & Eventsmenu-bracket
            Are you interested in attending one of our online or onsite event?
          • Product Trainingsmenu-bracket
            Customer success is our priority. Increase your skills in the use of Questel’s software
          • Product Newsmenu-bracket
            A platform dedicated to software and platforms news and evolutions
          • Best-in-class Customer Experiencemenu-bracket
            Our goal is to exceed our clients' expectations and share best practices
          • IP Trainingmenu-bracket
            Increase the IP-IQ of your entire organization with engaging IP training programs
          • Newsletter subscriptionmenu-bracket
            Sign up for our quarterly patent and trademark newsletters and set your email preferences below.
          • Resource Hubmenu-bracket
            Stay up-to-date with industry best practices with our latest blogs
    • About Questelmenu-bracket
      • Careers →menu-bracket
        • Login Pages →menu-bracket
          • Learn & Supportmenu-bracket
            • Learn and support
                • Webinars & Eventsmenu-bracket
                  Are you interested in attending one of our online or onsite event?
                • Product Trainingsmenu-bracket
                  Customer success is our priority. Increase your skills in the use of Questel’s software
                • Product Newsmenu-bracket
                  A platform dedicated to software and platforms news and evolutions
                • Best-in-class Customer Experiencemenu-bracket
                  Our goal is to exceed our clients' expectations and share best practices
                • IP Trainingmenu-bracket
                  Increase the IP-IQ of your entire organization with engaging IP training programs
                • Newsletter subscriptionmenu-bracket
                  Sign up for our quarterly patent and trademark newsletters and set your email preferences below.
                • Resource Hubmenu-bracket
                  Stay up-to-date with industry best practices with our latest blogs
          • About Questelmenu-bracket
            • Careers →menu-bracket
              • Login Pages →menu-bracket
              EN
              questel-menu
              Federal rule of evidence 902 abstract
              Blog Post / Published, June 20, 2023

              A Guide to Federal Rule of Evidence 902: How to Avoid Litigation Collection Minefields

              Back to Resource hub
              Back to Resource hub
              overview

              Original doeLEGAL Source - 2020, By Adam Bowers, JD. 
              Revised April 25, 2023

              Pronounced changes to the Federal Rules of Evidence (FRE) have occurred over the past years. Some are broader in scope, while others create more dramatic effects on the eDiscovery process.  The amendment to Federal Rule of Evidence 902 has caused many corporate entities to question whether they should continue to allow self-collections of their own litigation data or if they will avoid risks and exposure by hiring a 3rd-party professional service provider to oversee the collection tasks. 

              The favorable news for US-based corporations is that the amended Federal Rule of Evidence 902 does not require forensic collection experts. Still, there remain some critical reasons to consider seeking the expertise of an outside legal collections expert to ensure proper procedures are in place and followed.

              Introduction to the Amended Federal Rule of Evidence 902

              Attorneys must understand and optimally participate in identifying, preserving, and collecting their clients' ESI (Electronically Stored Information). Today, courts are more tech-savvy and less forgiving of any ignorance regarding eDiscovery collection practices. This paper provides an overview of self-collection and a cost-benefit analysis of the DIY (do it yourself) model from a lawyer's perspective, not a marketing perspective. An important distinction is drawn here because doeLEGAL and Questel are not forensic collection companies; we offer best-of-breed data collection techniques and practices, using advanced technologies and partners to ensure clients can make effective decisions. The intent is to take an honest look at the issues surrounding how corporate clients gather and identify ESI data to present strong evidence during litigation.

              NOTE: This blog is not to be considered legal advice. If you need legal advice, consult with a state-licensed attorney. With that said, let's look at the changes Federal Rule of Evidence 902 brought to life and its impact on eDiscovery collections.

              Dangers of allowing employees to conduct legal holds, manage their own data, and administer a self-collection

              With eDiscovery technology evolving rapidly, companies often get mired in the weeds, forgetting that humans remain a considerable part of the litigation equation. One past case exemplified the significant expense of allowing employees to preserve their own litigation data: GN Netcom, Inc. v. Plantronics, Inc.  The case has become so recognizable in eDiscovery circles, much like Zubulake, that it joins the infamous "single name club" – it's now known as "Plantronics." In this case, a senior member of management instructed his sales team to delete certain emails and other data in direct contradiction to a company-instituted legal hold on those email accounts.  The intent of the sales manager was seen as malicious, and the Delaware Federal Judge was not amused. The court sanctioned Plantronics in the amount of three million USD, plus associated fees and costs. While Plantronics proved to be victorious on the merits of the case, it was still liable for the millions in spoliation-associated costs: "They lost the battle but won the war." While the Plantronics case serves as an example of intentional destruction of litigation data, there are also less nefarious reasons that employees should not be left to manage their own data preservations or collections.

              Another notable case demonstrated why the process of a client collecting their own documents for litigation, commonly known as "self-collection," is risky and generally frowned upon by courts unless specific circumstances warrant it. Self-collection can potentially jeopardize the client's best interests and the integrity of the case. In fact, one judge expressed deep concerns regarding this practice, as evidenced in EEOC v. M1 5100 Corp., d/b/a Jumbo Supermarket, Inc., Civil No. 19-cv-81320 (S.D. Fla. July 2, 2020).

              When clients collect their own ESI for litigation, they may not completely understand the legal and ethical responsibilities involved. This can lead to issues such as over-collection or under-collection due to concerns about self-incrimination or conflicts of interest. Attorneys should instruct their clients to avoid self-collection practices since they must certify a client's self-collection and production efforts (as required by FRCP 26(g)). While self-collection is not inherently flawed, self-selection often poses significant risks in the legal process.

              What is self-collection?

              Before we get too far into the concepts of preservation and collection, let's define "custodian self-collection" using the two methods used most often. One is where the custodians are responsible for preserving, searching, and identifying their data while IT would do the actual collection (gathering of ESI). The second is where the custodians are responsible for preserving, searching, identifying, and collecting their own data. Each method has many of the same challenges and risks, but the first method is more common in business, so we will use that as our reference.

              In a past webcast, 62% of the attendees were concerned with spoliation risks associated with custodian self-preservation. However, in a survey of corporate counsel, 47% of organizations relied on custodian self-preservation more than 75% of the time. A clear split exists between what they know is right and doing what's right. Another thing to keep in mind when exploring how not to over-collect comes from employing a "collect everything" approach to preservation, a practice that creates its own apparent issues, such as increased costs, larger volumes of data to review, and potential risk in other legal matters.

              Federal rule of evidence 902 how companies use collections

              An additional example of the dangers of custodian self-collection comes from Nat’l Day Laborer Org. v. US Immigration and Customs Enforcement Agency, government employees from several different agencies attempted to compile data in connection with a FOIA (Federal Rules of Evidence Freedom of Information Act) request. There was a general lack of supervision, and the employees were Federal Rules of Evidence to search their own email accounts. But several ex-employees never had their emails searched at all, which prompted Judge Scheindlin to order the parties to meet again and confer to formulate search criteria and procedures. Scheindlin pointed out that there was no clear identification process in place, and the employees were directed to identify personally created data, which was not a normal work duty. One of the major issues was that those government employees were not even aware of where their custodial data was stored, so when they merely searched their shared drives, many records were entirely overlooked.

              Despite spending thousands of hours and hundreds of thousands of dollars on the exercise, the court opined that "Transparency is indeed expensive, but it pales in comparison to the costs to a democracy of operating behind a veil of secrecy".  The courts have long disfavored custodian self-collection because it is not systematic, repeatable, and defensible. Judge Scheindlin went so far as to say, "Most custodians cannot be 'trusted' to run effective searches[…]"  This may explain why Federal Rule of Evidence 902 was amended to require the certification of a collection by a "qualified person."  Attorneys should be involved in all aspects of the preservation and collection of their clients' litigation-data, no matter who performs the physical collection. But the new Federal Rule of Evidence 902 does not directly speak to attorney involvement.

              It is notable that the Chancery Court of Delaware had all but placed an outright ban on unsupervised self-collection of employee data.  In Roffe v. Eagle Rock Energy GP, LP, et al, CA No. 5258-VCL (Del. Ch. April 8, 2010), the Court of Chancery addressed party self-selection of the documents to be produced in litigation. “This is not satisfactory. Attorneys should not rely on their clients to search their own email systems. There needs to be a lawyer who makes sure the collection is done properly.”

              Where, oh where, has my data gone?

              Federal rule of evidence 902 person pressing digital forensics

              The over-collection of litigation data is often the norm, and we explored some of the dangers you face in doing so already. Collecting enough is not the same as over-collecting. Steve Bunting, CEO of Bunting Digital Forensics, said, “You never know when a spoliation claim will come up, and getting everything up front puts you in a far better position down the road.”  By creating a forensic image of a device or server, you may just be capturing data that you did not know you would need later. For instance, imaging a laptop will save the entire hard drive, including something called "Federal Rules of Evidence space". Without getting too technical, Federal Rules of Evidence space is the part of a drive that contains deleted items or file fragments. When someone deletes a file, devices will break it into several pieces and send it to the hard drive's Federal Rules of Evidence space. A skilled forensic expert may be able to retrieve and reconstruct ESI from this Federal Rules of Evidence space, which could be important if opposing counsel is accusing your client of intentional or negligent spoliation.

              So what's the bottom line here when it comes to self-collection problems? It's really quite simple: most employees don't understand what to collect or from where to collect it. This is where a forensic collections expert can help unravel this problem by creating a "data map" that shows all custodial devices (office, mobile, and personal), any instance of third-party data hosting (emails, social media, sales platforms, etc.), and internal and external storage locations. This visual depiction can be beneficial during a self-collection because it provides a "treasure map" to the data that can be easily understood and actioned.

              Any reasonable attorney must take into account the human factor and safeguard against risks, including the intentional deletion of data and the sluggishness of their client's employees.

              Federal rule of evidence 902 practical tips

              Federal Rule of Evidence 902: What's the attorney's role in the process?

              While we won't cover the legal hold process in this whitepaper, it involves many of the same issues as a collection, including the identification and supervision that the collection process presents.  In short, it is impossible to collect what has not been preserved, and it is equally impossible to preserve what has not been identified. With so much at stake, responsibility for preservation and adequate collection practices falls on the attorney. Because of this added responsibility, involvement in the process throughout the life cycle of litigation is crucial to protecting the client's best interests.

              Early in the identification process, a litigation attorney must be vigilant about what custodial data is involved and where that data is stored. First, the scope of the litigation determines the breadth and depth of the attorney's responsibility to safeguard any data that may fall within that scope.  This practice is not limited to data they know to be part of a current litigation, but extends to data that may be part of future litigations.  In effect, the FRCP and the Federal Rules of Evidence make an attorney the fiduciary of litigation data for current or potential future litigations.

              How does this relate to self-collections? Even attorneys involved in the litigation do not always know what data or evidence may be relevant, so it is reckless to believe that employees possessing ESI will be able to make this judgment. The best course of action is to meet with opposing counsel and design a legal hold that will reasonably capture as much relevant ESI as possible. This may include scheduled meetings with identified or potential custodians to ensure compliance with legal holds.

              It is important to point out that the ABA has expressly recommended that attorneys understand their client's use of technology (Rule 1.1 comment 8). Additionally, most US states have made technology competency a part of their Model Rules of Professional Conduct. However, some of the language used by the states is quite vague and speaks to a standard of care akin to avoiding negligence.

              One final area that should be addressed is the "chain of custody." An attorney should maintain a proper, well-documented ESI chain of custody, which starts with the identification and collection of the litigation data and continues throughout the litigation's life.  Any alteration to collected data is traced back to the party in control of it at the time of the alteration. Comparing the hash values is a quick and easy way to identify if a document was altered, but this also presumes that metadata has been preserved and collected. Treat ESI like you would any other piece of trial evidence. It is essential to know and understand the life cycle of the trial evidence to maintain accurate records of your efforts.

              Conclusion to the Attorney's Guide to Federal Rule of Evidence 902 – Avoiding Self-Collection Minefields

              Investing money upfront to hire a professional or train internal employees to perform forensically sound collections can stave off future pitfalls associated with using and reviewing litigation data.  Keeping in mind that the most expensive aspect of an eDiscovery project is the time that attorneys or paralegals spend reviewing the ESI that was collected, it becomes even more apparent that investing in proper collection practices is cost-justified. Familiarize your team with Federal Rule of Evidence 902 to ensure you follow the amended rule and provide the best advice to your client to protect everyone's best interests! In the digital data era, the Federal Rules of Evidence Rules will continue to evolve to match the current needs. 

              There are many moving parts to eDiscovery: Human, technical, legal, and ethical. By ensuring that companies follow the proper legal holds and collection practices, an attorney may perfectly position themselves to safeguard their client from possible sanctions for spoliation and reduce the resources spent by litigation support and review professionals. Whatever the amount of money that might be saved by following a DIY model of self-collection, this will certainly be outweighed by extra resources spent by litigation support professionals, reviewing attorneys, and the need to hire trial experts to authenticate the data collected. 

              The best defense is staying up-to-date on trends and requirements for ESI in litigation. This whitepaper covering Federal Rule of Evidence 902 is one part of that information-sharing initiative Questel is driving for the Legal market. When exploring if you should engage in ESI self-collection, consider the old English sailing proverb, "A stitch in time saves nine," which loosely means that a timely effort today can prevent more work later, is still applicable to modern-day litigation practices.

              For specific advice or more insight on the information shared in this blog, get in touch with our experts.

              Adam Bowers is a former employee of doeLEGAL, A Questel Company. Adam is an eDiscovery expert, LLM candidate, a former business owner, and legal technology practitioner who helps law firms and attorneys navigate the complex world of eDiscovery.

              Questel

              A world leader in intellectual property and innovation management.

              • Patent
                • IP Intelligence Software
                • IP Management Software
                • Preparation & Prosecution Copilots
                • Patent Services
                • Patent Strategy & Administration
              • Trademark
                • Clearance & Watch Platform
                • IP Management Software
                • AI Assistants for Trademark Productivity
                • Trademark, Design & Domain Services
              • Innovation
                • Innovation Management Software
                • Innovation Services
              • Solutions
                • Artificial Intelligence in IP
                • Integrated IP Ecosystem
                • Solutions for Law Firms
                • Solutions for Life Sciences
                • Solutions for R&D and Innovation
                • Language Solutions
              Stay in touch !
              Your email address is only used by Questel to send you the news, updates and offers. You can unsubscribe at any time by clicking on the unsubscribe link at the bottom of the newsletter. For more information about the Processing of your Personal Data by Questel, please visit our privacy policy page.
              © 2025 Questel. All rights reserved.
              Consent choices
              • Cookies policy
              • Data Privacy Policy
              • AI Policy
              • Legal notice